I am Trading a Manual Accord For a Big SUV! What Car Should I Buy?

Clint loves his guide Accord but it surely’s not the best transportation for 3 rising youngsters. He thinks it’s time to improve to an enormous household hauler that can comfortably seat the children and a few gear. He is working with a wholesome finances however doesn’t need to go overboard. What automotive ought to he purchase?

(Welcome again to What Car Should You Buy? Where we give actual folks actual recommendation about shopping for automobiles. Do you need us that can assist you discover a automotive? Submit your story on our type.)

Here is the situation:

I’m 35, married, with 3 youngsters (6, 5, and three months previous). I at the moment drive a 2018 Honda Accord Sport 1.5t with 6 spd guide transmission with 40k miles. I LOVE THIS CAR! I’m comfortable that I lastly satisfied my spouse to let me purchase a guide transmission automotive once more, however she received’t let me educate her the right way to drive it. This sometimes causes logistics points, however not typically. My spouse has a minivan (Odyssey) that we additionally love due to the sliding bucket seats that present quick access to the third row.

While my Accord is enjoyable to drive and does in reality match a pumpkin seat and two booster seats it’s a tight match, and my huge youngsters wrestle to succeed in between the booster seats to buckle themselves in.

This mixed with the truth that my spouse can’t drive a stick has me considering it’s about time to commerce in for a full-size SUV. Historically I haven’t been a fan of Chevy and Ford, however I do know their dependability has improved particularly with their vehicles. The 2023 Pilot has me excited with it’s rumored extra boxy look and I used to be excited in regards to the 2023 Sequoia though the early evaluations are fairly disappointing. The 3 row Rivian seemed intriguing, however I’m undecided if I belief the model but.

What ought to I purchase to haul round my household of 5 to high school, sporting occasions, and quick journeys? The 80k price ticket on a few of these Tahoes, Yukons, and Suburbans is difficult to abdomen and I wish to keep nearer to 70k OTD.

Quick Facts:

Budget: $70,000

Location: Cincinnati, OH

Daily Driver: Yes

Wants: 3 rows, luxurious really feel, reliability

Doesn’t need: Something loopy costly

Expert 1: Tom McParland – Save Some Cash For Some Nice Vacations

Clint, I’m going to warn you now that various the commenters are going to insist you don’t actually want to surrender your guide Accord since you might have an Odyssey within the fleet. But I perceive the logistical hassles you’re going through, and if an improve is what you’re searching for, so be it. That being mentioned, I don’t assume it’s essential to go together with the large SUV like a Tahoe or one thing, and also you even talked about that the extra fairly sized all-new Pilot appeared interesting.

I recommend you take a look on the Kia Telluride, it’s one of many hottest SUVs for a purpose. I’ve even spoken to patrons who had been contemplating similar-sized Volvo and Mercedes 3-r0w SUVs however opted for the Kia as a result of they thought it was “Almost as nice for a lot less.” The Telluride is on the bigger aspect of the spectrum for mid-sizers and received’t be fairly as thirsty as one thing like a Tahoe. A top-of-the-line SX Prestige X-Line Pro maxes out round $54,000, however I guess you’d be very proud of all of the options in the usual SX with an MSRP of round $49k when geared up with AWD.

Given the recognition, it may be difficult to discover a Telluride at MSRP, however it’s doable so long as you’re affected person sufficient to attend for an order.

Expert 2: Collin Woodard – No, Get the Other Telluride

Tom is correct right here, Clint. Sure, you might most likely make the Accord work, but it surely sounds such as you don’t actually need to. And that’s OK. You’re not a teen who wants Mom and Dad’s approval whenever you purchase a automotive anymore. You’re an grownup with a spouse and youngsters. If you need to exchange your guide sedan with an enormous SUV, do it. Living your life making an attempt to maintain all of the keyboard warriors comfortable is a recipe for distress.

The Telluride appears like precisely what you’re searching for, however since Tom already really helpful that one, I’ve to give you one thing totally different. So what about its company cousin, the Hyundai Palisade? It’s a totally totally different alternative and positively isn’t the Telluride. After all, it has utterly totally different sheet steel, a unique title, and a unique badge on the hood. How’s that for differentiation?

Jokes apart, the Palisade does have some benefits over the Telluride. If you just like the styling higher, that’s positively one. Adding all-wheel drive can also be barely cheaper on the Palisade, and the Telluride doesn’t provide power-folding third-row seats. And lastly, the Palisade is an IIHS Top Safety Pick+, whereas the Telluride is just a Top Safety Pick.

Either one will most likely make you content, and there’s likelihood seller markup would be the greatest differentiator between the 2, however I nonetheless say go for the Palisade. It’s a unbelievable family-friendly crossover, and the Telluride was already taken.

Expert 3: Andy Kalmowitz – No, Get The American Telluride

It’s no secret that I’m a little bit of a Stellantis man, however don’t like my affinity for the wildest American automaker cease you from making the right alternative in your subsequent car. The Jeep Grand Cherokee L is the precise automotive you’re searching for.

I’ve spent many tons of of miles on this rig, and the one factor you’ll by no means run out of on a protracted journey is house. Your youngsters received’t even be capable of discuss amongst themselves at the back of a Grand Cherokee L as a result of they’re so far-off from each other.

With adjustable air suspension and Jeep well-known four-wheel drive system, you’ll be able to take your loved ones wherever they should go whereas being swaddled within the most interesting American luxurious inside outdoors of issues that price over $100,000. In reality, you may get any variety of totally different GC L fashions in your value vary. You’ll be capable of discover the fitting one for you!

It’s obtained an actual presence on the highway (and plenty of chrome) that the Korean twin choices simply don’t have, in case you ask me.While it might not be quick in a straight line, the three.6-liter Pentastar V6 can rise up and go when it’s essential to. As an added bonus, the GC L has nearly the perfect lane maintain and radar cruise management techniques I’ve used thus far.

Do the fitting factor, Clint. Mopar, or no automotive.

Expert 4: Erik Shilling – No, Get the Telluride

I used to be knowledgeable earlier this morning {that a} portion of our readership believes that we’re within the bag for Kia, which is an unbelievable idea, since we’re always writing about how completely made Kias are.

In any case, Tom is plainly proper that this Cincinnatian wants a Telluride, which many readers will view as giving up on life. The downside with that’s that life is about love and acceptance, which on this case means accepting the truth that one has a household to take care of, and desires a correct automotive geared up to do this.

The Telluride is that automotive. It is huge, comfortable, secure, and, importantly, not a minivan, since having a second minivan within the household is fairly cursed. It’s additionally nicely below the $70,000 finances; you’ll be able to spend the remainder at Kings Island. I drove the Telluride when it debuted, concluding that Kia was going to promote a shit-ton of Tellurides, which is strictly what occurred.

Good luck discovering one within the present market, however, as Tom says, keep affected person. The Telluride is definitely worth the wait.